Have been gone a lot lately. Back to Campbell's Myths to Live By
These passages contrast Freud and Jung. Freud being the boneheaded rationalist whereas Jung while modern does finds a wisdom and depth from the religious and mythical.
His (Freud's) psychology, however, being of an essentially rational
kind, insufficiently attentive to the more deeply based, irrational impulsions
of our nature, he assumed that when a custom or belief was shown to be
unreasonable, it would presently disappear. And how wrong he was can be shown
simply by pointing to any professor of philosophy at play in a bowling alley:
watch him twist and turn after the ball has left his hand, to bring it over to
the standing pins.
........
And thus Freud, like Frazer, judged the worlds of myth,
magic, and religion negatively, as errors to be refuted, surpassed, and
supplanted finally by science.
..............
An altogether different approach is represented by Carl G.
Jung, in whose view the imageries of mythology and religion serve positive,
life-furthering ends. According to his way of thinking, all the organs of our
bodies—not only those of sex and aggression—have their purposes and motives,
some being subject to conscious control, others, however, not. Our
outward-oriented consciousness, addressed to the demands of the day, may lose
touch with these inward forces; and the myths, states Jung, when correctly
read, are the means to bring us back in touch. They are telling us in picture
language of powers of the psyche to be recognized and integrated in our lives,
powers that have been common to the human spirit forever, and which represent
that wisdom of the species by which man has weathered the millenniums. Thus
they have not been, and can never be, displaced by the findings of science,
which relate rather to the outside world than to the depths that we enter in
sleep. Through a dialogue conducted with these inward forces through our dreams
and through a study of myths, we can learn to know and come to terms with the
greater horizon of our own deeper and wiser, inward self. And analogously, the
society that cherishes and keeps its myths alive will be nourished from the
soundest, richest strata of the human spirit.
.........................
They speak, therefore, not of outside events but of themes
of the imagination.
............................
Taken as referring not to any geographical scene, but to a
landscape of the soul, that Garden of Eden would have to be within us.
...............
...............
That would seem to be the meaning of the myth when read, not
as prehistory, but as referring to man’s inward spiritual state.
